|
 |
|
Nah Simon I'm afraid you are mistaken. Multi attack does very little for Flaming Crush. It does not get any of the BP multipliers and does not increase the base damage of the magic hit. It's literally like adding extra avatar melee attack hits.
This becomes extremely apparent if you try Flaming Crush with Nirvana AM3 and without, the damage will be the same.
I went to test this and you are right. I guess saying things from memory is not the best idea anymore. I'm too old, my apologies.
Another thing I forgot is that this game and 'consistency in mechanics' never even lay next to each other. |
|
 |
|
|
Sorry, there are only Team Yagyu and Team Onion in this shipper thread.
And obviously Team Yagyu is the coolest, because Onion sucks.
|
|
 |
By Kaffy on 2025-02-18 14:37:30 |
|
Avowed manages to make combat less appealing than Skyrim, 14 years later.
|
|
 |
By kaht on 2025-02-18 14:19:28 |
Very cool! And well timed as there is the official MtG Final Fantasy Universes Beyond set releasing this year. I believe they've said all of the numbered titles will be featured so should be getting some official FFXI x MtG cards as well.
Spoilers for some of the cards started yesterday. 2 FF14 cards have been spoilered so far, which is good news cause it means they're not excluding the MMO games. No FF11 representation yet, tho...
 |
|
 |
|
I think most players would be better served with Rank 1 giving a full Prime or something the way early iterations of the Bonanza did with REMA weapons.
Most players would benefit more from a mythic/ergon R1 prize vs Bonanza weapons. The Bonanza weapons are all overvalued by SE and should probably be in like the Rank 2 category max. By comparison, a Yagrush or Idris is miles more valuable than a Diamond Aspis or Brave Blade, even if they can already be obtained through normal means. |
|
|
|
|
There was the chocobo shield and then the crafting shields came and afaik left chocobo shield completely in the dust. They'll probably do the same with Bonanza weapons eventually. Maybe it's what they currently building up to with besieged, who knows.
|
|
 |
|
|
Good point!
|
|
 |
|
|
Yeah, we got RDM god on our side leading us to victory!
But anyways... we found our 6th person and we're good now. :)
|
|
 |
By Keyser on 2025-02-18 10:23:02 |
I love this concept so much, thanks for releasing this! Thanks for the comment! I'm glad you like it :D |
|
|
|
Much respect to you! This is one of the most valuable compiled resources. I have often found myself asking "uh, which blue spell does <effect> and what <potency> is it?" Super helpful! |
|
|
By Asura. Narr on 2025-02-18 09:47:21 |
YouTube Video Placeholder |
|
|
By Tarage on 2025-02-18 09:45:01 |
|
It's been chugging tonight...
|
|
|
By Tarage on 2025-02-18 09:13:43 |
|
Just shout if anyone needs it for the points clear. I did yesterday and ended up with 6 people, and I'm on dead *** Ragnarok. Only was shouting for an hour while I waited for the reservation to kick in.
|
|
 |
|
2 weeks until Monster Hunter: Wilds. In you have the time, they say Kingdom Come: Deliverance 1 and 2 are quite good.
I heard Kingdom Come: Deliverance 2 broke even one week after release. The developer expected 2 to perform even better than 1.
(This game is also on my wishlist once I cleared current backlog, lol)
Western games are still alive and kicking.
Another RA conspiracy sent through the woodchipper. |
|
 |
By mhomho on 2025-02-18 08:04:22 |
|
How is this even a debate? You get the katana and sell the account.
|
|
|
|
|
Out of those weapons, I like the Katana one more
|
|
 |
|
It's a fantastic weapon for any job, some of which can't use Naegling, and even if they can an incredibly interesting option to use on content with WS wall mechanics.
I'm hypothetically Team Onion Sword III as well, Sechs. However, Fast Blade II is Fusion, so actually the niche is a bit smaller than this because you can't use it as an alternative to Savage to dodge the WS wall in situations when you're trying to avoid skillchains. |
|
|
|
|
Nah it's for sure all the physical hits including multi attack proc. It works like that for hybrid WSs and FC. Ma proc are super potent on hybrids, but BP and WSD too.
|
|
|
|
Carbuncle.Maletaru said: »Lullaby can be the longest sleep in the game and is aoe Yeah but you don't cast Horde Lullaby I/II with Ghorn, tipically °-°
I get what you're saying, I was just trying to say that I'm a bit in the middle, with magic debuffs feeling a bit more consistant to me in the landing rate compared to songs (but then that's probably because of immunobreak rather than the direct consistency itself).
But in the end all these points are ultimately moot given how cheap and fast it is to make a Ghorn. |
|
 |
|
|
I got booted and couldn't get back on for a bit. Just logged back in though. Still a little slow to get in.
|
|
|
|
And ghorn is still needed for Macc! So really you guys are saying it is another necessary bard instrument that is useful sometimes. Ghorn only days were simpler times. Technically yes, but Ghorn "only" has CHR+10, Sing+25 and Wind+25
CHR gives different values of macc, we can round of around +10Macc
Sing converts at roughly 1:1 so around +25 macc.
Wind converts (estimated) at 1:0.3 so around 7.5 macc.
Overall ~42 macc which is, uhm, it's something. Maybe not an impressive % of your overall Macc when you're easily gonna get around ~1646 macc in your debuff song midcast set.
I mean sure ~42 is good, not sure I'd call it vital though. Wouldn't call BRD debuffs "vital" for most strategies these days anyway (have they ever?)
And let's not forget BRD has a mechanic that doubles your overall macc once every 10 mins, even more than Elemental Seal if you compare it to that. |
|
|
|
I recently wondered the same thing and found there was no such table in existence and I have no idea why
That is... until today!
Using information from bgwiki I built a spreadsheet for all spell data
I'm sure some of the data is inconsistent or incorrect - but it's just copied from the wiki so it's only as good as the information held there
If someone would like to copy it and enhance it / use it however you like, go for it!
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1XbN6IPn1OvQzfcaA6__7ksL_xse540r8SKpPSxhrda0/edit?gid=0#gid=0 |
|
|
|
Exactly why would my BRD want to use one flute, when she can use many and she even gets some herpes.. *** I meant harps!
If you're after all the RAPEMs, you'll be getting a lot more than just herpes.
Carbuncle.Maletaru said: »And ghorn is still needed for Macc! So really you guys are saying it is another necessary bard instrument that is useful sometimes. Ghorn only days were simpler times.
The RAPEMs all end up being useful and not invalidating each other.
That’s the worst version of that acronym
You're right, I forgot to include Unity, Dynamis, and Bonanza weapons. RAPED BUMS |
|
|
|
|
Exactly why would my BRD want to use one flute, when she can use many and she even gets some herpes.. *** I meant harps!
|
|
 |
|
Carbuncle.Maletaru said: »And ghorn is still needed for Macc! So really you guys are saying it is another necessary bard instrument that is useful sometimes. Ghorn only days were simpler times.
The RAPEMs all end up being useful and not invalidating each other.
That’s the worst version of that acronym |
|
|
|
That makes perfect logical sense in theory Simon, you have a strong point.
But then in reality there's been such a huge difference in damage output when judging non-nirvana options, and the numbers sorta always skewed towards BPD (which is applied twice, both for the physical part and for the magical part, kinda like what WSD does for hybrid WSs) and pet mab compared to multiattack.
All of this to say that I'm sure multiattack has a strong relevance, as emphasized by your logic, but ultimately it seems like it falls behind other options in terms of efficiency for the final numbers?
Like I said, I don't have the time to check which is better in sim or on average. I just wanted to clarify that TA proc on Flaming Crush will double its damage (assuming its not gonna be limited by 99999 ofc, which can be a valid factor in many cases), because it will add 2x 1.0 ftp hits to 2x 1.0 ftp hits. |
|
|
|
And ghorn is still needed for Macc! So really you guys are saying it is another necessary bard instrument that is useful sometimes. Ghorn only days were simpler times.
I mean, the ghorn only times were really short and at the time very, very few people had a ghorn at all.
That's one thing I really enjoy about BRD, even though it seems to end up being a complaint of so many others. The RAPEMs all end up being useful and not invalidating each other.
I recognize this balance is a lot harder to maintain on weapons that are exclusively (or mostly) used to do damage to enemies, but for a lot of other jobs, there are definitive winners and losers, and lots of straight up trash weapons. BRD gets to use basically all of them though.
Aenaes kinda sucks imo, but I guess if you want radiance, umbra, or to use exenterator then that's a thing.
Miracle cheer isn't an ultimate weapon but bonanza weapons kinda occupy the same category and BRD once again got a clearly good instrument, but one that doesn't invalidate any other instruments. It's incredible game design IMO. |
|
|
|
Obvious/silly question first: Are you loading XiPivot in your Windower init.txt?
What does your overlays (with an s) path look like? Here's my settings file: Code
<?xml version="1.1" ?>
<settings>
<global>
<cache_enabled>false</cache_enabled>
<cache_max_age>600</cache_max_age>
<cache_size>2147483648</cache_size>
<debug_log>false</debug_log>
<overlays>Changes2023,Remapster,NextLore</overlays>
</global>
</settings>
|
|
|
By . on 2025-02-18 04:07:49 |
|
Ugh, Im hungry
|
|
|
By . on 2025-02-18 04:07:52 |
|
|
