All this to say I am questioning the shield because not having an iLv shield equipped when taking any direct or AoE physical damage seems crazy to me to throw away the increased block chance.
I don't mind giving it up depending on the situation. In any content that matters you're to be floored to 6%. I suppose you could boost that up to 11% with an Ambu back? I think Banhammer put it best, just view it as grip.
Is everyone going to make a new idle toggle when you tanking adds in Gaol NMs?
I've got six different idle sets for my WHM: Refresh, DT, PDT, Misery, ResistSilence, Reraise (Sphere body). That's overkill and far more than anyone needs, but I appreciate each of them whenever their niche situations arise.