|
Let's start a riot?!?!
By clearlyamule 2020-06-08 21:12:44
You could argue they are less willing to use any force as many have already across the country have already stated as they threaten to quit
By volkom 2020-06-08 21:42:30
i wonder how many cases of police brutality were reported when the victim/person being arrested was on drugs that made them harder to subdue
[+]
Bahamut.Ravael
Server: Bahamut
Game: FFXI
Posts: 13643
By Bahamut.Ravael 2020-06-08 21:56:02
News flash: poverty rates are recorded demographics.
They’re just one factor among many recordable and unrecordable demographics. Don’t get mad that I can’t read your mind, you didn’t even specify. The subject had been bought up a few times before, including by your buddy kireek, so I assumed you'd get it.
I have some faith that you're not a "because they are inherently more violent/savages/tribal" person, so if I raised the issue that there are other statistics which can go towards explaining the differences in crime rates and you didn't think of poverty then I don't know what else you'd think I was proposing.
No, it's more of an issue where statisticians tend to be more hardwired into thinking about the myriad of confounding variables that could be screwing with any particular data set. Beyond that, my mind doesn't automatically latch on to whatever key words came up in any conversations you had with my "buddies". I think they're wrong sometimes and the feeling is mutual, I'm sure. No big deal.
As for other factors that could be influencing the issue, there are a bunch that we could list that could tip the scales towards a propensity for higher crime rates. Economic status, cultural influences, religion, political ideologies, racial profiling by police, and a host of other things. Is it possible that genetic factors can play into this too? Absolutely. There are plenty of studies where they're trying to track down markers for aggressive behavior, for example.
It's worth noting that any of those factors that I listed could be playing against the higher crime rate. For example, if you could create an experiment where you isolate just the genetic factors you might find that races that tend to commit more crimes are inherently less likely to commit said crimes, but other factors tip the scales to the other side. I'm sure some would argue that poverty is the biggest weight on that scale. Others, racial profiling. Others, music? Who knows? While there are studies out there drawing correlations, they can't prove causation. The end result is that it's all mostly speculation and it probably always will be.
[+]
Bahamut.Ravael
Server: Bahamut
Game: FFXI
Posts: 13643
By Bahamut.Ravael 2020-06-08 22:07:50
i wonder how many cases of police brutality were reported when the victim/person being arrested was on drugs that made them harder to subdue Do they gain super strength when high or just become immune to pain?
Okay, I have to share a crazy story from my past.
About 12 years ago I was on my way to visiting a friend when I saw a scrawny dude diving into trashcans along the road. He then ran into someone's yard out of view. Flash forward several minutes later, I was at my friend's house talking to them in the doorway, and they guy literally hopped over the fence and ran inside the home. After about a minute of people panicking trying to figure out what to do with this guy who is clearly VERY high on drugs, a lady cop walks right by the house, obviously having been alerted previously by the neighbors that something was going on in the neighborhood. High Guy immediately runs back out of the house right to where the policewoman was standing, and a struggle ensues.
Long story short, about a dozen police, two tazings, and a hog-tie later, the guy is finally subdued. Certainly a lack of pain contributed, but who knows what else made the wiry dude so hard to take down. Drugs are bad, mmkay.
[+]
Bahamut.Ravael
Server: Bahamut
Game: FFXI
Posts: 13643
By Bahamut.Ravael 2020-06-08 22:14:30
So basically what you're saying is that pulling random statistics out without giving acknowledgement to the entire myriad of interrelated factors is pointless. Also, because causation cannot be derived from correlation those statistics are not relevant without understanding the impossible - all of those variables and their interrelations. I agree, that's exactly what anyone arguing against the over simpliciation of quoted statistics (e.g. commodus, kireek, kn, etc.) are doing.
Yet if you do believe that then why would you post a blunt statement like this that doesn't acknowledge this complexity, or that correlation does not prove causation (e.g. that they are criminals because they are black, extrapolating from the statistic you quoted)?
The entirety of the U.S. population isn’t having encounters with police, so drawing from that population for comparison is moot. Look at the demographics for those committing crimes. Even then it would be a logical fallacy to claim causation, but at least you’d be closer to the mark.
I see where you're going with this, but I think it's pretty clear in my quote. By acknowledging that it would still be a logical fallacy to draw a conclusion even when narrowing down the sample population, I'm absolutely acknowledging the complexity of the argument. It may still be apples and oranges, but at least it's no longer celery and oranges.
Bahamut.Ravael
Server: Bahamut
Game: FFXI
Posts: 13643
By Bahamut.Ravael 2020-06-08 22:32:17
Allow me to make the issue with what you said more clear. You said:
Look at the demographics for those committing crimes. Even then it would be a logical fallacy to claim causation, but at least you’d be closer to the mark. Implying that it is black people that commit crimes and hence are involved with encounters with the police. Race being a demographic factor. What I was trying to highlight is that you can replace "black people" with "impoverished people" and still come to the same conclusion (wealth being a demographic). Why do you choose race here to make your point?
You acknowledge that there exist other variables but stop short of acknowledging the elephant in the room. Openly racist posters (e.g. commodus) do this, but as a statistician why would you not distance yourself from such simple quoting of statistics while just giving a fuzzy refuation of doing so?
I didn’t bring racial demographics into the conversation. I simply narrowed the goal posts. Bringing poverty into the argument would have changed the goal posts that were already established. You’re reading way too much into this.
[+]
Bahamut.Ravael
Server: Bahamut
Game: FFXI
Posts: 13643
By Bahamut.Ravael 2020-06-08 22:46:16
Allow me to make the issue with what you said more clear. You said:
Look at the demographics for those committing crimes. Even then it would be a logical fallacy to claim causation, but at least you’d be closer to the mark. Implying that it is black people that commit crimes and hence are involved with encounters with the police. Race being a demographic factor. What I was trying to highlight is that you can replace "black people" with "impoverished people" and still come to the same conclusion (wealth being a demographic). Why do you choose race here to make your point?
You acknowledge that there exist other variables but stop short of acknowledging the elephant in the room. Openly racist posters (e.g. commodus) do this, but as a statistician why would you not distance yourself from such simple quoting of statistics while just giving a fuzzy refuation of doing so?
I didn’t bring racial demographics into the conversation. I simply narrowed the goal posts. Bringing poverty into the argument would have changed the goal posts that were already established. You’re reading way too much into this. Not at all. It was clearly an intentional attempt to proclaim the issue is black people being criminals without explicitly stating it. Adding the comment about it not being a sole factor and that correlation isn't causation is just a further attempt to distance yourself from outright making the claim while also not denying what you actually believe. This is standard alt right tactics in play.
No, you’re crossing a line now. We were having a meaningful discussion. If your purpose here is to weasel your way into calling me an alt-right racist, then screw you. I’m done.
Asura.Veikur
By Asura.Veikur 2020-06-08 23:07:28
This is why I propose tranquilizers... An idiot could easily OD someone and kill them. Like so.
Bahamut.Ravael
Server: Bahamut
Game: FFXI
Posts: 13643
By Bahamut.Ravael 2020-06-08 23:10:34
Look at the demographics for those committing crimes. Pretending that you weren't implying race is laughable. What other demographic were you referring to if not that?
I'm just asking why you wouldn't outright raise the elephant in the room when even kireek mentioned poverty as a major factor, more so than race, and I consider him far more towards that scale of people than you.
I was implying race. Racial demographics were the topic of discussion before I commented. This isn’t hard. I’m sorry that I didn’t post what you think I should have posted, but that doesn’t give you carte blanche to insult me with accusations of racism. That’s not how discussions work.
Server: Asura
Game: FFXI
Posts: 34187
By Asura.Kingnobody 2020-06-08 23:53:50
Allow me to make the issue with what you said more clear. You said:
Look at the demographics for those committing crimes. Even then it would be a logical fallacy to claim causation, but at least you’d be closer to the mark. Implying that it is black people that commit crimes and hence are involved with encounters with the police. Race being a demographic factor. What I was trying to highlight is that you can replace "black people" with "impoverished people" and still come to the same conclusion (wealth being a demographic). Why do you choose race here to make your point?
You acknowledge that there exist other variables but stop short of acknowledging the elephant in the room. Openly racist posters (e.g. commodus) do this, but as a statistician why would you not distance yourself from such simple quoting of statistics while just giving a fuzzy refuation of doing so?
I didn’t bring racial demographics into the conversation. I simply narrowed the goal posts. Bringing poverty into the argument would have changed the goal posts that were already established. You’re reading way too much into this. Not at all. It was clearly an intentional attempt to proclaim the issue is black people being criminals without explicitly stating it. Adding the comment about it not being a sole factor and that correlation isn't causation is just a further attempt to distance yourself from outright making the claim while also not denying what you actually believe. This is standard alt right tactics in play.
No, you’re crossing a line now. We were having a meaningful discussion. If your purpose here is to weasel your way into calling me an alt-right racist, then screw you. I’m done. Isn't that how many posters here make the argument now?
If they don't like the answer you give them, they make one up for you.
For example.
They want you to say something you don't agree with, just so it makes their argument easier. So, they project their image onto you.
It happens all the time.
By Prong 2020-06-09 03:33:31
In the UK the left wing is the antisemitic side
That's oddly interesting, the same thing has developed in the US the past 12 years as well. And the irony of that is, Hollywood is overwhelmingly Jewish, from actors to producers and directors AND overwhelmingly liberal. But there has without a doubt been an annual increase in antisemitism from our left and our left media outlets.
[+]
By Prong 2020-06-09 03:36:28
[+]
Cerberus.Hideka
Server: Cerberus
Game: FFXI
Posts: 742
By Cerberus.Hideka 2020-06-09 04:59:06
i wonder how many cases of police brutality were reported when the victim/person being arrested was on drugs that made them harder to subdue Do they gain super strength when high or just become immune to pain?
yea, depending on the drug they can. theres all kinds of stories of dudes flying sky high taking multiple tazers to down, or easily ragdolling multiple officers - specially on ***like PCP or other stimulants. i think there was a case i heard like ten years ago of a dude on crocodil that took seven officers to subdue because he was basically ragdolling them. i think there was a recent case of some dude on flakka that took eleven people and multiple tranquilizers to subdue him?
like some of these upper drugs are no *** joke man.
Cerberus.Hideka
Server: Cerberus
Game: FFXI
Posts: 742
By Cerberus.Hideka 2020-06-09 05:03:45
This is why I propose tranquilizers...
i mean, in floyds case in particular, he'd have died INSTANTLY from a tranquilizer. the dude was sky high on fentanyl which is a massive depressant and would have very likely instantly stopped his heart if the toxicology reports on how much fentanyl was in his system are to be believed.
i believe the report came back that he was already in OD territory, and its one of the major keypoints on why the cops will probably get off on this since the autopsy showed no evidence of asphyxiation or damage to his neck.
[+]
Bahamut.Ravael
Server: Bahamut
Game: FFXI
Posts: 13643
By Bahamut.Ravael 2020-06-09 05:17:11
i wonder how many cases of police brutality were reported when the victim/person being arrested was on drugs that made them harder to subdue Do they gain super strength when high or just become immune to pain?
yea, depending on the drug they can. theres all kinds of stories of dudes flying sky high taking multiple tazers to down, or easily ragdolling multiple officers - specially on ***like PCP or other stimulants. i think there was a case i heard like ten years ago of a dude on crocodil that took seven officers to subdue because he was basically ragdolling them. i think there was a recent case of some dude on flakka that took eleven people and multiple tranquilizers to subdue him?
like some of these upper drugs are no *** joke man.
Which makes me wonder just how common that is. I’ve seen videos of tough guys getting dropped in an instant by tasers, so watching an emaciated drug addict shrug off two hits is really something.
Cerberus.Hideka
Server: Cerberus
Game: FFXI
Posts: 742
By Cerberus.Hideka 2020-06-09 05:32:07
with PCP? its incredibly common as far as i know; they go into a completely delerious state where they feel little to no pain, and their muscle limiters basically stop working and they literally hulk out;
I think the most relevant case i can remember is like back in 2012 iirc; there was a dude who got blasted out of his mind on PCP, and then went running around with a gun. i think he got stopped by the cops, then fought them off, stole a cop car and a gun, then went home and held his mother at gunpoint, then got shot something insane like twelve times, and tazed two to four times, beaten by like five different cops with batons and still wouldnt go down. As insane as it sounds i think this dude actually survived all of that too if im not losin my ***.
[+]
Cerberus.Hideka
Server: Cerberus
Game: FFXI
Posts: 742
By Cerberus.Hideka 2020-06-09 05:36:30
Found it
https://wjla.com/news/local/college-park-shooting-near-umd-campus-leaves-one-hurt-77621
got a few facts wrong, but the general 'smoked pcp, survived twelve gunshot wounds, multiple tazings, got naked, stole a cop car, held mother at gunpoint' all happened.
Quote: No officers were shot during the chain of events, but police say that McKoy, who is remarkably listed in good condition at an area hospital, was shot more than a dozen times, shocked with a Taser and clubbed with police batons while they tried to apprehend him.
So yea been out of the loop, has the rebellion began?
Is sublime gonna make a 2020 edition? What cities are popping off? What was the "last straw"?
Stay tuned for more excitement in 2020....
Edit: diverting the latest corona shenanigans from random thoughts.
|
|