Maybe should just lop this in with the overall guide, but there are so few actual threads so why not put it here.
I made the thread to discussion what combinations different thf's use in different situations. I just did a little test while out meriting on 115~ twitherym on which offhand works best with my Mandau, here's my dagger guideline:
Easy content, DC mobs and below - Mandau/Atoyac
119+ content - Mandau/Izhiikoh
Content where hate is to be avoided - Mandau/Sandung (working on a -enmity set to use, too)
Parsing my merits I had Mandau/Izhiikoh at 770-780ish DPS. And Mandau/Atoyac with OAT/Crit rate+4 I was at 820-830ish DPS. Not the most conclusive of testing since I relied entirely on my trusts for haste cap instead of my geo dualbox indi-haste (had her using indi-fury) so there is some leeway there, but I think the difference was big enough to show Atoyac is the winner there.
I temporarily lapsed my judgement and had been using Atoyac exclusively, and wondered why my acc was so low on some difficult content, and realized that each dagger's acc/att is based off of its own skill rating on the weapon. So I'm assuming that once you get to 119+ atoyac's lower rating will quickly drop off its faster attacking in terms of overall DD.
Have you guys found the same thing? Anything different? What about if you're not a relic user?