Even if only 20% of the population votes, it would take every single citizen in Wyoming to have the same level of voting power to vote than one section of New York City.
And you think that's fair?
...you're asking me if I think it's fair that people who neglect to vote lose out on representation?
Of course that's fair. That's the very point of voting. Expressing your will. If you don't vote in a 1:1 system, that's your own damn fault. If you don't vote in an electoral college system, who can blame you, because your vote doesn't matter in most states where the electoral votes are nearly assuredly going to go against you anyhow.
So, instead, let's have 2 regions of the nation decide your vote instead of whatever state you live in?
Considering that most presidents get elected on the popular vote already your argument doesn't make a lot of sense. Not everyone from New York votes democrat. Not everyone from Texas Votes Republican.
Those states already get weighted higher because of their greater number of electoral votes. CA has 18 times more voting power than Nevada in the electoral system. Is that fair? If your concern is each state be equally represented why not just give each state one electoral vote?
With the electoral college the way votes have more to do with focusing elections on swing states and winning over and all the rest just vote the way they always do.
In any case I personally think the only thing that would change are the venues that presidential campaigns would focus on.
Because now we are going to a different argument.
If I were to push my agenda in changing to a new voting system, I would change it to a state-only voting system where that there are a total of 51 votes in the election, and each state (plus DC) gets exactly 1 vote, and that vote is determined by the popular vote in that state.
Since the majority of states are red in general elections, as show by this map:
My voting system will nearly guarantee a Republican controlled government for a very long while.
However, that still wouldn't be a fair method of signifying a representative government, because population factors will be removed completely. I would never advocate a system where only one factor is taken into consideration in a complex matter such as our government.
Electoral college system is our best solution in a true representative government. It allows citizens in lower population states have a voice while also allowing population factors and populist vote to have their own voice.