I didn't want to say Chrono Trigger or FF6 because I figured anyone born within the golden age of RPGs would know that if you didn't play them/finish them your breathing privileges were revoked instantly.(lol)
Anyway back to my list.
5. Golden Sun: The Lost Age-Man it was great. It tied up lose ends that the first one had, opened up room for a sequel(which I think is important too), and when you see the main characters hug their parents again you can't help but get teary eyed.
6. Pokemon Red & Blue-I don't care who you are but the first time you finished the Elite Four, saw your team on the Hall of Fame, and saw the credits roll you didn't feel like you did something amazing. Maybe it was cause I was really young but I remember how great I felt and bragging it to all the neighborhood kids lol.
7. FFXI:CoP-Yes CoP. Oldschool CoP before level caps were removed from the BCNMs. It was SUCH an accomplishment. I remember screaming "Yataa!!!" over my vent mic once I finally did it back in the day lol. Finally getting Rajas Ring, getting to hear a vocal song in FFXI, and seeing the story come to close was just plain breathtaking.