By Phoenix.Purraj 2012-01-12 00:07:45
I play both and am geared extremely well on both (my Twash is 90 also) and DNC will win in a pure DPS, most of the time. DNC's main ability to deal greater DPS comes from the AF3+2 body giving a ridiculous DW %, a higher tier of DW, and the ability to have 10% more JA haste at all times; It's almost not fair. That being said, in alot of situations where you can't JUST TP something to death, THF can hang close and even surpass it. THF offers other areas of expertise though, such as being a better EVA tank (thought not by a huge margin), having TH, hate control and is a far better puller. DNC can certainly shred stuff, but THF is some pretty hardcore DMG. I think people that haven't played either far undervalue their DMg potential. A good bit of this argument is relative to how well the player is geared and knows said jobs though.
Sidenote: DNCs stock in overall DPS went up a small percentage with the addition of Exenterator. They can now hang even tougher on THF without having to rely on force crits. (outside of course)