Jesse Cox on youtube does a thing called "Scary Game Squad" and they played it, when the credits rolled the first thing someone said was "If you don't have anything nice to say, don't say anything at all".
It's just such a badly written story, and it looks deep but then isn't.
I really enjoyed Catherine's character development though, and having a character like her in a video game was refreshing.
Made me feel less alienated since someone like that to relate to is so uncommon. Did you think the big post credits ending ruined the game? or helped it