Fenrir.Nightfyre said:
Heading out in a couple minutes so I don't have time to write the math out myself here concerning DA vs OA2-4, but you can see for yourself here:
http://bellsouthpwp2.net/k/i/kinematicf/FFXI/DPSSpreadsheets/
Designed by Motenten/Kinematics. The PLD xml is still a bit behind afaik but assuming the OA2-4 is in the spreadsheet you could get a decent approximation at BLU values if you played around with it a bit. Should see at least a 15% loss in damage going from DA to OA2-4. NIN (which I also see people ask about OA2-4 for for some reason) loses nearly 20% of their DPS with the switch and Kannagi 85 mainhand, not that DA Enchu +2 is particularly good for NIN either.
I have no doubt that the DA offhand is better for pure damage output with any WS. I have the DA polearm and even on drakesbane (4-hits, meaning DA can only increase the WS by a small amount) and I'm putting out stupid numbers on things if you take in account that I have no WS gear. (Sold it all to pay for other jobs). But, regardless, I am most certainly sticking with my plans: Almace/Occ2-4 swords. For a few reasons (Both PLD & BLU Lv90).
1: I almost always sub DNC, and the TP gain from 2-4 sword really can't be beat. -Ignoring Kraken club as, in this case, BLU can't use.
2. TP can be used for so much more than just weaponskills for BLU. Although if I did have Chant Du Cygne, I'm sure I'd be much more frugal about my TP.
3. And idk about the rest of you, but with all that MP/refresh in abyssea, I can just spam spells and get hate pretty easily. So doing slightly less spike damage will be just fine by me.
4. Hopefully sometime between now and Lv 99, we'll see a spell with good damage that can close SC off Chant Du Cygne. And even if not, I'm confident that we won't see another sword WS out-damage it.