Color Perception & Optical Illusion Topic
|
Color Perception & Optical Illusion Topic
it was obvious blue with black frill to me and that light was causing a change in shade of the color. didn't even think about overexposure of the camera until it was mentioned.
Valefor.Prothescar said: » im not arguing the initial perception issue, rather the issue of those who vehemently declare the dress as gold/white despite there being obvious photographic evidence to the contrary That doesn't change what they see. Anna Ruthven said: » Quetzalcoatl.Valli said: » A simple IQ test would show who sees what colors. It's blatantly blue and black. Quote: Blue and black. Theres an exercise in my psych 101 book that has you order the words by the colors that they are....and it was so aggravating. colors are hard :( specially when they cheat :( that's precisely what I'm talking about. my grievance is with those who deny the dress being blue/black despite this evidence being available and glaringly obvious. initially seeing the dress and seeing it as a different color than someone else is fine, that happens all the time. it's those who persist in it being something that it's not that I have a problem with.
Also, doesnt surprise me the bout of stupidity that is the argument started on Tumblr.
Valefor.Prothescar said: » that's precisely what I'm talking about. my grievance is with those who deny the dress being blue/black despite this evidence being available and glaringly obvious. initially seeing the dress and seeing it as a different color than someone else is fine, that happens all the time. it's those who persist in it being something that it's not that I have a problem with.
[+]
Wait, what color IS the dress really?
Anna Ruthven said: » Wait, what color IS the dress really?  owner of the exact dress taken in the original photo, getting her picture taken at a wedding:  Anna Ruthven said: » Wait, what color IS the dress really? Yes, it really is a blue dress with black lace.
I can see it just fine in some pictures but in others I can only see white and gold
Kalila said: » Yes, it really is a blue dress with black lace. Kalila said: » Not going to bother formatting this, but it sums it up well~ I'd love to see someone explain how people could perceive this as having been in bright light from all directions. I'm not saying it's wrong, but it's apparently not how my brain works and I'm always curious to know how other people's brains do work.
[+]
Bismarck.Dracondria said: » I can see it just fine in some pictures but in others I can only see white and gold  Then the girl who uploaded the picture thinking it was cool that she saw a white dress with gold lace, and her friend could only see a blue dress with black lace, uploaded this showing her wearing it at a wedding: after the internet lost it arguing about what color it really is, and people calling each other stupid, or their monitor isn't calibrated, or they have a color blindness problem, etc etc. The people in my work were commenting about that. Even the tv here showed that, even called a doctor to explain whats going on.
Personally, i see it black and blue, but lots of colleagues said they saw white and gold. Its interesting. But honestly, i just was thinking, poor of that girl. Now in every place in the world, millions of guys stared her butt for some mins just to check her colors. Shiva.Onorgul said: » With the background being so very bright, my natural first assumption was the dress was shadowed. This operated on the idea of a single general source of the light (e.g., the Sun). It didn't occur to me that everything was over-exposed (and the camera in question was probably going crazy trying to compensate) with the bright patch of light along the top-left quadrant. I'd love to see someone explain how people could perceive this as having been in bright light from all directions. I'm not saying it's wrong, but it's apparently not how my brain works and I'm always curious to know how other people's brains do work. Verda said: » Honestly I strongly feel that perception and our ability to both be self aware of it and change it is tied to our ability to not only solve hard problems but also our ability to think through any problem and relate to other people. And it is a cryin shame that so many people get stuck in their perceptions and write others off as stupid or wrong or idiotic without trying to exercise perception and thus understanding of the world and others. It should really be taught in every school from a very early age, our ability to relate to others and see things from many different perspectives is a very necessary trait to the betterment of humanity as a whole. Pretty amazed that Valli can post with a non-working brain
We live in a world with people who argue about the right color of dress. Let that sink in for a minute.
Bismarck.Dracondria said: » Pretty amazed that Valli can post with a non-working brain I don't exactly blame people who don't get it, but the people who refuse to see both sides, and proceed to argue against the people who see gold/white, I do blame because they are the people that even made this "a thing" to begin with. Bismarck.Dubai said: » We live in a world with people who argue about the right color of dress. Let that sink in for a minute. Now that we know the color of the dress.
What about this? 
[+]
Kalila said: » Bismarck.Dubai said: » We live in a world with people who argue about the right color of dress. Let that sink in for a minute. Perception, as I've pointed out, is not limited to one thing or another, and how one perceives one thing, can tell us a little about their thought processes. It also tells us, that even when presented with the same information, regardless of it's intent, color, design, etc., they are going to look at, and extrapolate something entirely different, slightly different, or the same. Example: I can say an apple is red. I wouldn't be wrong, but for someone who's never seen a red apple, because there are green and yellow apples, they could argue about the color of the apple, or even the shade of an apple's color based on the context of lighting, shading, and so forth. A red apple could become various shades or values of red quite easily, enough to fool some people into thinking it's pink, or a light violet, or crimson scarlet. It isn't about what is really there, but what information is being perceived in place of reality. What we perceive to be true is often at odds with what reality presents to us.
[+]
It's not about the mind whatsoever. It's about the light shown on the dress.
Simple as that. If you don't understand that human made light is yellow and gives things tints, then you're dumb. Not trying to be rude at all, it's just fact. It's true that new lights are becoming less yellow. That's the bottom line of it. (It does help that I've worked in lighting, professionally, though.) Then you would know, that professionally speaking, white light products have been around for close to 20 years.
And that the majority of fluorescent lights in department stores, at weddings, and so forth, use white light products, to showcase their merchandise in the most flattering way possible for the sole psychological reason that it shapes what a customer perceives about said products, particularly clothes. So far though, despite working in lighting professionally, you sound as dense as molasses in winter.
[+]
|
All FFXIV and FFXI content and images © 2002-2024 SQUARE ENIX CO., LTD.
FINAL FANTASY is a registered trademark of Square Enix Co., Ltd.